PS5 vs Xbox: which is cheaper to own?
The cheaper console to buy is not necessarily the cheaper one to own.
Hardware is the smallest number
Both manufacturers sell consoles on very thin margins because the money is made afterwards. Over three or four years the games, the online subscription and any storage expansion cost considerably more than the machine did.
So comparing entry prices answers the wrong question. The comparison that matters is the machine plus how you will actually play for the next few years.
The three costs that differ
- Subscriptions. Both charge for online play and both offer game-library tiers. The tiers differ enough that your habits decide which is cheaper, not the headline.
- Storage expansion. One ecosystem uses proprietary cards that cost considerably more than ordinary drives. If you keep many games installed, this is a real number.
- Disc or digital. A disc drive lets you buy pre-owned and sell on. For a heavy buyer that outweighs the up-front saving on a digital machine within a couple of years.
Bundles are where retailers compete
Since standalone hardware prices are near-identical everywhere, shops differentiate by attaching a game, a controller or a subscription. Price the console alone, price the extras alone, and count only the extras you would genuinely have bought.
Storage expansion is the clearest structural difference
One of these takes an ordinary M.2 NVMe drive bought from any computer parts retailer, in a competitive market with real price pressure. The other takes a proprietary expansion card sold by a single manufacturer, in a market with none. For anyone who installs a lot of games that gap grows over the life of the console and is almost never counted in a comparison of the two.
Subscriptions are not equivalent and should not be compared head to head
- One ecosystem puts its own new releases into the subscription on day one, which changes what you need to buy separately.
- The other weights its subscription towards a back catalogue plus the online play requirement.
- Both renew for as long as you play, so the multi-year figure dwarfs the hardware difference.
- Tiers differ in what they include rather than how well they work, which makes the cheapest tier the right default for most people.
Resale is the number nobody counts
Disc-based games can be sold on; digital ones cannot. If you buy and finish several games a year, the resale value of physical copies is the largest single figure in this comparison, and it favours whichever console you buy with a disc drive. Choosing a digital-only machine to save money at the till is often the more expensive decision over a few years.
Before you buy
- Decide disc or digital from how you buy games.
- Total the subscription over the period you will own it.
- Price storage expansion if you keep a lot installed.
- Compare bundles against the parts bought separately.
- Check the standalone price across shops to find the floor.