Screwfix vs B&Q vs Wickes: which is cheapest?
They are not three versions of the same shop, and the cheapest depends on what you are buying.
They serve different jobs
Screwfix is built around trade collection: a narrow, deep range of tools and fixings, ordered ahead and picked up from a counter. B&Q is a full retail shed with garden, kitchens and decorating alongside the tools. Wickes sits between the two, with a strong trade and building-materials leaning.
That shapes the pricing more than any general "which is cheapest" answer could. Each is keenest in the category it is built around.
Where each tends to be keenest
- Screwfix: power tools, fixings and consumables, particularly bare tools and trade multipacks.
- B&Q: decorating, garden and anything own-brand, where the range is widest and the own-label pricing is aggressive.
- Wickes: building materials and kitchens, plus timber, where the trade leaning shows.
- All three: clearance, which is genuinely unpredictable and worth checking before assuming.
Trade accounts and multipacks change the answer
All three run trade pricing that is not visible in a straight retail comparison, and all three price multipacks well below unit price. On consumables — screws, fixings, blades, paint — buying the right pack size frequently beats choosing the right shop.
Click-and-collect is the structural difference
One of these is built around trade collection — order online, collect from a counter in minutes, branches on industrial estates with long opening hours. The others are retail sheds you walk around. If you are mid-job and need a part today, the collection model wins regardless of the listed price, because a delivery slot tomorrow has a cost that does not appear on the invoice.
Own-brand ranges are where the margin sits
- Each chain runs own-label tools and materials that are frequently the same factory output as a known brand at a lower price.
- Timber and sheet materials are priced per unit of length or area, and the sizes stocked differ between chains — which makes direct comparison harder than it looks.
- Cut-to-size services vary by chain and change the real cost of a sheet material job considerably.
- Clearance ends and discontinued lines are deep in these shops and never appear online.
Returns and account terms differ more than prices do
Unused-material return windows, whether you need the receipt, and whether an account gets you extended terms vary meaningfully between the three. On a job where you deliberately over-order and take the surplus back, the return policy is worth more than any price difference on the materials themselves.
Before you buy
- Check all three, not just the one nearest you.
- Convert to price per unit on anything sold in packs.
- On cordless tools, confirm whether the listing is a bare tool or a kit.
- Factor collection — all three do it, and it removes delivery entirely.